When To Walk Away After a Home Inspection in New Jersey

Published on: August 18, 2025

When purchasing a property, a home inspection is a crucial step that cannot be overlooked. The report tells you exactly what shape the place is in, from the roof all the way down to the foundation. You get inspection benefits up front instead of surprises down the road.

Sometimes those findings feel like a punch to the gut. Big repairs pop up, costs add up, and you might ask if you should walk away. This is the moment to call a New Jersey real estate attorney. A seasoned lawyer can study the inspection, check your purchase contract, and talk you through every option. You stay in control.

The Matus Law Group has helped buyers across the state protect their money and peace of mind. Talk with a New Jersey real estate attorney from the team, see what can be repaired, negotiate credits, or decide to move on before more cash is on the line. Call The Matus Law Group today at (732) 785-4453 to schedule a consultation.

Importance of Home Inspection in the Buying Process

A home inspection is your chance to peek under the hood of the place before you sign anything. The inspector checks the bones of the house, the wiring, the plumbing, the heating and cooling, the roof, and everything that keeps a home safe and comfortable. You walk away with a clear picture of what works and what needs attention. Through a thorough inspection, buyers can:

  • Make informed decisions based on a complete understanding of the property’s condition.
  • Identify potential issues that may not be visible during a regular viewing.
  • Assess the extent of repairs or renovations required.
  • Evaluate if the property aligns with their expectations and budget.
  • Mitigate risks by uncovering potential hidden structural issues or health hazards.
  • Avoid making a poor investment and protect themselves from unforeseen expenses.
  • Leverage the inspection findings during negotiations for repairs or adjustments to the sale price.

Recognizing the importance of home inspections empowers you to take a proactive approach to protect your investments. It turns guesswork into clear numbers, helps you weigh risks, and lets you shape the deal so it fits you, not the other way around.

Home inspections in New Jersey are governed by specific laws and regulations that aim to ensure consumer protection and transparency. It is essential for both buyers and sellers to be familiar with the legal framework. Key aspects include:

  • Licensed Home Inspectors: Home inspectors in New Jersey must obtain a license from the New Jersey Real Estate Commission. This licensing ensures that inspectors meet professional standards and adhere to a code of ethics when conducting inspections.
  • Property Disclosure Statement: Sellers in New Jersey are legally obligated to provide buyers with a property disclosure statement. This document outlines any known defects or issues with the property, ensuring that buyers have a complete understanding of its condition.
  • Right to Inspect: Buyers in New Jersey have the right to conduct a home inspection before finalizing the purchase. This allows them to thoroughly evaluate the property and make an informed decision based on the inspection findings.
  • Repair Negotiations: Based on the inspection report, buyers can negotiate with the seller to address any issues discovered during the inspection. This can involve requesting repairs, credits, or a reduction in the sale price to account for the necessary fixes.
  • Due Diligence Period: The home inspection is typically conducted during a due diligence period specified in the purchase agreement. This period allows buyers to thoroughly evaluate the property and negotiate any repairs or adjustments before finalizing the purchase.

Buyers in New Jersey can navigate the home inspection process with confidence and ensure their rights are protected by becoming familiar with the state’s legal framework. Making informed decisions and safeguarding an investment in a property is achievable when buyers work with licensed inspectors and leverage the provided disclosure statements.

Key Deadlines in the New Jersey Home Inspection Process

Once the contract is fully signed and delivered to both buyer and seller, the three-business-day attorney-review period begins immediately and ends at 11:59 p.m. on the third full business day, excluding weekends and New Jersey legal holidays. During this window, either attorney can tweak the inspection clause, adjust time frames, or even cancel the deal without penalty.  Because the clock pauses on holidays, confirm with your lawyer whether a long weekend effectively extends this window.

When the attorney review ends, the inspection contingency clock starts. Most New Jersey contracts give buyers ten calendar days to order, complete, and review the general home inspection, plus any agreed-upon specialty checks such as termite, radon, underground-oil-tank, mold, septic, or sewer-scope inspections. Use this time to book a licensed home inspector, receive the written report, and talk through the findings. Because a radon canister must sit sealed in the home for forty-eight hours, schedule your inspector early so lab time fits inside the same ten-day block.

Your five-day period to request repairs begins as soon as you receive the written inspection report. If you fail to send a timely repair letter that lists every defect you want addressed and attaches the full report, the property is generally deemed accepted “as is.” Missing this deadline can expose you to default fees or loss of your earnest-money deposit, so set calendar reminders and ask your attorney to draft the letter if you feel rushed.

After you deliver the repair letter, the seller typically has up to seven days to answer. They may agree to some fixes, offer credits, refuse entirely, or propose an extension for further testing (common if radon or well-water results are still pending). Their written response triggers your buyer-decision window, often three to five days, during which you must choose to accept the property as-is, renegotiate again, or walk away with your deposit.

Any concessions that survive negotiation should be memorialized in an Inspection Addendum (also called a Rider) signed by both sides and forwarded to the title company so the promises carry through to closing. Keep in mind that appraisal, mortgage-commitment, and title-search deadlines run in parallel. Slipping on the inspection timetable can push those later milestones and may require a formal contract extension.

Because every contract is negotiable, verify whether a particular deadline is measured in business or calendar days and whether “day one” is the date of the last signature or the following day. If a federal or state holiday falls inside any period, ask your attorney whether the clock pauses. Staying clear on these definitions and documenting every change in writing protects your leverage at the bargaining table and keeps the transaction on schedule.

It is advisable to reach out to a New Jersey real estate attorney as soon as questions arise. The right counsel can track each date, remind you before a deadline hits, prepare amendment language, and ensure that any agreed-upon repairs or credits are enforceable at closing.

New Jersey Real Estate Attorneys

Christine Matus

Christine Matus is a seasoned real estate attorney and the visionary behind The Matus Law Group. For over two decades, she has blended legal experience with a heartfelt commitment to community service, supporting families across New Jersey with both legal advocacy and nonprofit engagement.

  • Member of the Asian Pacific American Lawyers Association and ABA Advisory Panel
  • Former General Counsel for Southern Cross Management, Inc.
  • Contributor to community-focused newsletters and elder law publications
  • Volunteer mediator and Eucharistic Minister

Types of Home Inspections

Home inspections come in various forms, each focusing on specific aspects of the property. Buyers can make informed decisions and ensure a thorough property evaluation by learning about the different types of inspections available. Here are the key types of home inspections:

General Home Inspection

A general home inspection is the most common type of inspection. It covers the overall condition of the property, including the structural elements, electrical systems, plumbing systems, HVAC systems, roofing, and more. A general home inspection provides buyers with a comprehensive assessment of the property’s condition and identifies any potential issues or areas in need of repair.

Radon Testing

Radon is a radioactive gas that can seep into homes through the soil. Prolonged exposure to high levels of radon can pose health risks. Radon testing involves the use of equipment specifically designed to measure the concentration of radon gas within the property. Testing for radon is especially important in areas known to have high radon concentrations, and it is recommended for buyers to ensure a safe living environment.

Termite Inspection

Termite inspections focus on identifying the presence of termites or any termite damage within the property. Termites can cause significant structural damage if left untreated. A professional termite inspection examines the property for signs of termite infestation, such as mud tubes, damaged wood, or discarded wings. This inspection helps buyers detect any termite-related issues and take appropriate measures to address them.

Septic System Inspection

Properties with septic systems require a separate and detailed inspection to assess their functionality and condition. A septic system inspection involves evaluating the tank, drainage field, and associated components to ensure proper operation. This inspection is crucial in identifying any potential issues or maintenance needs, allowing buyers to make informed decisions about the property’s septic system.

Structural Inspection

A structural inspection focuses specifically on the property’s structural elements, such as the foundation, walls, floors, and roof. This inspection aims to identify any structural defects, such as cracks, sagging, or settlement issues. A thorough structural inspection helps buyers understand the integrity of the property’s foundation and other structural components, ensuring their long-term stability and safety.

Buyers can customize their evaluation process by familiarizing themselves with the various types of home inspections available. This understanding enables them to address specific concerns and consider the unique characteristics of the property. Factors such as the property’s location, age, and other considerations may prompt buyers to opt for additional inspections alongside the general home inspection. This approach ensures a comprehensive assessment of the property’s condition.

Scenario Approximate Withdrawal Rate Context / Notes
General industry average 10–15% Common estimate across the U.S.
NAR estimate of failed transactions Up to 25% Share of terminated deals attributed to inspections
Homes with significant inspection findings 42% more likely to back out Higher cancellations when serious issues are uncovered
Overall pending sales cancellations (2025) 14.9% Includes cancellations during inspection period

Analyzing the Home Inspection Report

After the completion of a home inspection, buyers receive a detailed inspection report that outlines the findings and observations made by the home inspector. Analyzing this report is a crucial step in the decision-making process. Here are the key aspects to consider when reviewing the home inspection report:

Interpreting the Findings

Interpreting the findings of the home inspection report requires careful attention to detail. The report may include technical terminology and descriptions of various issues discovered during the inspection. Buyers should thoroughly read and understand the information provided, paying close attention to any areas that require further clarification. If there are any uncertainties or questions regarding the findings, consulting with the home inspector or seeking professional advice is recommended.

Recognizing Major vs Minor Issues

It is important to differentiate between major and minor issues identified in the home inspection report. Major issues typically refer to significant structural concerns, safety hazards, or systems that require immediate attention or extensive repairs. Minor issues, on the other hand, may include cosmetic imperfections or minor maintenance tasks that can be addressed over time. This distinction enables buyers to prioritize their concerns and determine the overall impact on the property’s value and livability.

Estimated Costs for Repairs and Upgrades

The home inspection report may provide insights into the estimated costs associated with necessary repairs, upgrades, or maintenance tasks. These estimated costs are crucial for buyers to assess the financial implications and feasibility of addressing the identified issues. Buyers can use this information to budget for repairs and upgrades and consider the overall investment required to bring the property to their desired condition.

While analyzing the home inspection report, it is essential to keep in mind that no property is perfect, and it is common for inspection reports to identify some issues. The goal is to evaluate the severity and extent of the issues and their potential impact on the property’s value, safety, and livability. This information will help buyers make informed decisions regarding their continued interest in the property, negotiation strategies, and overall investment plans. Consulting with professionals such as real estate agents, contractors, or real estate attorneys can provide further guidance and skill in interpreting and addressing the findings outlined in the home inspection report.

In New Jersey, buyers have the benefit of an attorney review period to safeguard their legal rights during the home-buying process. The attorney review period typically lasts for a few business days after the signing of the purchase agreement. During this time, buyers can consult with a real estate attorney to review the terms of the agreement and ensure their interests are protected. It is crucial to take advantage of this period to seek legal advice and address any concerns or modifications to the contract if necessary.

Negotiating Repairs or Credits with the Seller

After reviewing the home inspection report, buyers may identify issues that require repairs or upgrades. In such cases, buyers have the option to negotiate with the seller for necessary repairs or credits toward the purchase price. This negotiation process involves communicating the inspection findings and proposing a mutually agreeable solution. Working with a skilled New Jersey real estate attorney can provide guidance on negotiation strategies, ensuring that buyers are well-positioned to achieve a satisfactory outcome that meets their needs.

Withdrawal Rights in New Jersey Based on Inspection Results

In New Jersey, buyers have withdrawal rights based on inspection results. If the inspection uncovers significant issues that affect the property’s value or livability, buyers can choose to exercise their right to withdraw from the purchase agreement without penalty. This allows buyers to protect themselves from unforeseen expenses or risks associated with the property. However, it is essential to review the terms of the purchase agreement and consult with a real estate attorney to understand the specific conditions and deadlines for exercising withdrawal rights.

The post-inspection phase of the home-buying process is a critical time for buyers to act on their legal rights and evaluate their options. Leveraging the attorney review period, negotiating repairs or credits with the seller, and knowing their right to withdraw are essential steps that allow buyers to protect their interests and make informed decisions based on the inspection findings. Seeking guidance from a knowledgeable New Jersey real estate attorney ensures that buyers have the necessary support and insight to navigate these legal aspects successfully.

When to Consider Walking Away

Making the decision to walk away from a home purchase after the inspection is not an easy one, but certain circumstances may warrant it. Here are key factors to consider when determining if it’s time to walk away:

Structural Problems and Safety Concerns

If the home inspection reveals significant structural issues, such as foundation problems, extensive water damage, or severe structural deterioration, it may be a cause for concern. Structural issues can be costly to repair and may compromise the safety and stability of the property. In such cases, walking away may be the wisest choice to avoid potential hazards and significant financial burdens.

Major Financial Burdens

Discovering extensive repair needs or unforeseen expenses beyond what you are financially prepared to handle can be a strong indicator to consider walking away. If the cost of necessary repairs, renovations, or addressing code violations exceeds your budget or financing capabilities, it may be impractical or unwise to proceed with the purchase.

Environmental Issues

Environmental issues, such as high levels of radon, mold infestation, or the presence of hazardous materials like asbestos or lead paint, can pose serious health risks and necessitate costly remediation efforts. Depending on the extent of these environmental issues and their potential impact on the property and its occupants, walking away may be a prudent choice to prioritize your well-being and avoid the expenses and difficulties associated with remediation.

When Negotiations Fail

Negotiations with the seller following the inspection are an opportunity to address the identified issues and reach mutually agreeable solutions. However, if negotiations fail to yield satisfactory results or the seller is unwilling to address significant concerns, it may be an indication that walking away is the best course of action. It is important to remember that if the seller is not willing to address the inspection findings, it could indicate a lack of willingness to cooperate in resolving future issues that may arise.

While walking away from a home purchase is a difficult decision, it is crucial to prioritize your safety, financial well-being, and peace of mind. Consulting with a real estate attorney can provide valuable guidance and help assess the legal implications of walking away based on specific circumstances. Carefully considering the severity of structural problems, financial burdens, environmental issues, and the outcome of negotiations will enable you to make an informed choice that protects your interests and ensures a positive home-buying experience.

How Often Do Buyers Back Out After Inspection?

When considering the likelihood of a buyer backing out of a house purchase post-inspection, data suggests it’s not an uncommon occurrence. Industry insights indicate that approximately one in ten home sales don’t proceed past the inspection phase. The percentage of buyers who choose to terminate the contract after discovering inspection issues generally ranges from 10% to 15% across the nation.

This figure, however, isn’t uniform and can be influenced by a variety of factors. For instance, the prevalence of older properties in a given location can impact the rate at which buyers withdraw offers. Older homes often have more issues that are uncovered during an inspection, which can lead to a higher rate of deal cancellations.

Moreover, the National Association of Realtors (NAR) conducted a survey, which revealed that up to 25% of real estate transactions that ended prematurely did so because of inspection revelations. This suggests that while the baseline expectation is around 10-15%, certain circumstances, like the specific details uncovered during an inspection, can drive this figure higher.

Economic and seasonal trends also play a part in these statistics. In times of economic uncertainty or when the market is more volatile, buyers tend to be more cautious. This heightened sense of caution can translate into a greater propensity to back out after an inspection if any significant issues are identified. Thus, while the average remains fairly consistent, individual cases can vary widely based on timing, market conditions, and the specifics of the property in question.

The Process of Walking Away

Walking away from a home purchase after the inspection is a significant decision that should be approached carefully. Following the correct process and taking the necessary steps can help protect your interests and minimize potential repercussions. Here are the key aspects to consider when navigating the process of walking away:

Consulting with Your Real Estate Attorney

Before making the final decision to walk away, it is crucial to consult with your real estate attorney. They will review the terms of the purchase agreement, assess the inspection findings, and provide guidance on the legal implications of walking away. Your attorney will ensure that you understand your rights, obligations, and any potential consequences associated with the withdrawal.

Understanding the Consequences of Walking Away

Walking away from a home purchase may have consequences, depending on the terms of the purchase agreement and state laws. These consequences may include losing your earnest money deposit, potential legal disputes, or damaging your reputation in the real estate market. Being aware of these potential consequences enables you to make an informed decision and weigh the risks involved.

Submitting the Withdrawal Notice

To officially walk away from the purchase agreement, you must submit a written notice of withdrawal to the seller. This notice should clearly state your intention to withdraw from the agreement and reference the specific grounds, such as the inspection findings, that led to your decision. It is essential to follow the procedures outlined in the purchase agreement and adhere to any specified deadlines for submitting the withdrawal notice.

Protecting Your Earnest Money Deposit

If you have submitted an earnest money deposit, you will need to take steps to protect it when walking away. Your real estate attorney can guide you on how to properly handle the deposit based on specific circumstances. This may involve reviewing the purchase agreement for any contingencies related to the refund of the deposit and ensuring that you comply with any necessary documentation or procedures to request its return.

To navigate the process of walking away from a home purchase with confidence, it is important to adhere to these steps and seek guidance from your real estate attorney. With the assistance of your attorney, you will gain a comprehensive understanding of the legal implications involved, ensuring the protection of your interests and compliance with the required procedures and deadlines. Given that walking away from a home purchase is a significant decision, having the appropriate guidance enables you to proceed in a manner that safeguards your rights and reduces the possibility of adverse effects.

Do You Get Earnest Money Back If The Inspection Fails?

Think of earnest money as a show-of-faith deposit. You hand it over when you make an offer to prove you’re serious, and it usually sits in an escrow account until closing.

If your purchase contract has an inspection contingency, and most do, you’re protected. Schedule the inspection, review the report, and decide whether the issues are deal-breakers. If the place needs more repairs than you’re willing to tackle, you can walk away during the contingency period and get every dollar of your earnest money back.

But timing and reasons matter. Cancel for something not covered by a contingency, or wait until the inspection deadline has passed, and the seller can keep the deposit as compensation for taking the home off the market. On the flip side, if the seller breaches the agreement, the money comes straight back to you.

A careful review of the purchase contract is crucial, as it outlines the specific conditions and deadlines under which earnest money will be returned. Consulting with a New Jersey real estate attorney can help clarify these terms and safeguard your interests during the transaction.

The Aftermath of Walking Away

Walking away from a home purchase can have lasting effects and requires careful consideration of the aftermath. Navigating the post-walkaway period effectively requires a clear understanding of the implications and a proper course of action. Here are key aspects to consider:

Financial and Emotional Implications

Walking away from a home purchase can have both financial and emotional implications. Financially, you may have lost your earnest money deposit, incurred inspection and appraisal costs, and potentially missed out on other opportunities during the time spent on the failed transaction. Emotionally, you may experience disappointment or frustration. It is important to acknowledge these implications and take steps to mitigate any negative effects, such as focusing on rebuilding savings or seeking support from family and friends.

Preparing for Future Home Purchases

Although walking away from a potential home purchase can be discouraging, it is essential to prepare for future home purchases. Take the time to reevaluate your priorities, refine your search criteria, and learn from the experience. Consider consulting with your real estate agent and attorney to strategize for future transactions. Strengthening your financial position, conducting thorough research, and being vigilant during the home-buying process can increase the likelihood of a successful purchase in the future.

Navigating the aftermath of walking away from a home purchase requires introspection, addressing the financial and emotional implications, and preparing for future opportunities. Learning from the experience and taking proactive steps will help you regain momentum and approach future home purchases with renewed confidence and wisdom. Remember that every failed transaction provides valuable lessons that contribute to your growth as a buyer.

Working with an Experienced New Jersey Real Estate Attorney

Performing due diligence, including a thorough home inspection, is crucial in the home-buying process. It provides buyers with vital information about the property’s condition, allowing them to make informed decisions. Conducting proper due diligence allows buyers to uncover potential issues, negotiate repairs or adjustments, and safeguard their investments. Remember that the extra time and effort invested in due diligence can save you from future headaches and unexpected expenses.

In difficult situations, such as determining whether to walk away from a home purchase, seeking guidance from a skilled New Jersey real estate attorney is highly recommended. Our team of skilled New Jersey real estate attorneys at Matus Law Group provides quality legal services. We can protect your rights and offer valuable advice throughout the process. 

Our attorneys can review the contracts, negotiate on your behalf, interpret inspection reports, and assist with navigating the legal issues associated with walking away from the transaction. Having a knowledgeable attorney by your side ensures that you make informed decisions and mitigate potential risks.

Remember that purchasing a home is a significant financial and emotional investment, and it is crucial to approach it with careful consideration, thorough research, and the support of qualified professionals. With the right approach and professional guidance, you can make informed decisions and achieve a successful and satisfying home-buying experience. Contact Matus Law Group today at (732) 785-4453 to schedule a consultation.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Picture of Christine Matus
Christine Matus

FREE Webinar on Special Needs

Estate & Financial Planning.

4/11 at 4 PM